For regular followers, you will remember my little jaunt over to the land of the red, white and blue, to Denver Colorado to appear on Cool Tools. Haven’t forgotten the experience, from the flight on the A380 to getting around Denver, being on the show, meeting and working with Chris Grundy, visiting Rockler, and, well, the whole experience.
It all jumped back in mind when I was reading up about a tool sitting out in the shed, and heard it was about to be featured on….Cool Tools!
The tool in question: the Nova Comet II midi lathe, from Teknatool.
Nova Comet II
It is a very interesting addition to the midi lineup, and simply based on name, it has quite a pedigree.
There are a few other lathes in the same niche, so lets pull them all out, dust them off and see what we have here.
Jet Midi, Variable Speed
Carbatec Midi, Variable Speed
There are others, but these are the ones I have some familiarity with.
Must admit, I didn’t have variable speed on a lathe until I got my DVR. My old Jet midi lathe didn’t have the feature. Variable speed is pretty cool, and means you can quickly change the speed to suit what you are doing at the time, rather than stopping to change the belts (or simply ignoring the speed isn’t ideal, mores the point!)
Both the Jet and the Carbatec have the variable speed tacked onto the side, as if the lathe was designed without and on certain machines they get the upgrade. For both the Jet and Carbatec, this is pretty much the case.
The Comet has it designed to be much more integrally part of the lathe from the outset. This may just be an aesthetic, but it also means there isn’t a speed control box sticking out the side. Dust does build up, and objects do fall or hit things that are sticking out.
While we are looking at it, some other specs, side by side
| Specification |
Comet II |
Jet |
Carbatec |
| Price |
$639 |
$849 |
$799 |
| Speed |
250 – 4000 |
200 – 4300 |
250 – 3600 |
| Swing over bed |
300mm |
304mm |
355mm |
| Distance between Centres |
419mm |
510mm |
430mm |
| Reverse |
Yes |
No |
No |
| Weight |
32kg |
45kg |
39kg |
All have 3/4HP motors, indexing heads
So in the first rounds, the Comet II really is holding its own. Especially given the price.
There are some aspects that do come in though, and this is probably price-related. I like cams on the various movable items, and although it is only the tailstock, I would have preferred it to have been a cam.
Although the finish on all user areas is good, there are some rough castings underneath. The foundry really needs to invest in an angle grinder. It wouldn’t have been hard to tidy up the casting a bit more underneath.
Toolless access to the belt drive.
Other than those points, there are some distinct advantages too!
Reversible. The other lathes can’t run backwards! (Correct me if I am wrong (update – the Carbatec does))
Excellent access to the belt drive – much better than either of the others.
Ability to add accessories, such as a grinder (for sharpening chisels during turning)
It may be a bit lighter (weight is a bonus for lathes), but not too much so, and it does make it more transportable.
I’ll revisit the accessories when they arrive, but the concept is very interesting!
When I have a chance to really put the lathe through its paces, I will feed those experiences back. The initial testing didn’t reveal any issues.
So a very promising addition to the lineup, and at a rather cost-competitive price point! You can afford to add a Nova G3 chuck and still be ahead. Don’t forget, the 4 jaw self-centering chuck which is now the standard for wood turners was invented by Teknatool.
Like this:
Like Loading...
Filed under: Lathe, Manufactures and Suppliers | Tagged: Angle Grinder, Carbatec, Chris Grundy, Comet, Cool Tools, Denver, Lathe, MIDI, nova comet, Woodturning | 1 Comment »
